Notorious (more conspicuously so since December last year) for its violence against women, the city space is one that is increasingly intimidating to the single woman. Like any regular girl, I've had experiences in the past. Public masturbation, 'eve-teasing', the sudden swerve of a tinted car etc etc; most of my friends have shared similar stories of horror with me. We speak with a sense of resignation, to the affairs of the world. We've always been told; "This is how the system works", "Let it go, it's useless to fight, " "Just keep your head down", "Are you sure you didn't say anything?" There is of course the occasional burst of indignation, but nothing substantial. Yes. The public space is not mine anymore. Perhaps it never was, perhaps it was an illusion. MUST NOT RETALIATE- we've been told.
Conditioned to think of the city as not mine to roam freely in, I've always had this subconscious defensive streak. Don't trust anyone, they say. Don't get into arguments, don't roll down your windows. It's all a little overwhelming to be honest. We all have preconceived notions of each other in this city; somehow all of us seem bound by this external identity. We behave a certain way, like we are expected to.
I feel compelled to blog about this particular thought because of an incident that happened yesterday. At around 3:30pm, in Shahpur Jat I was trying to find myself a parking space, when while reversing my car bumped another. Now, I am not the best driver in the world, but yes I get around without hitting people's bumpers. The man driving the other car got out, and walked towards my car. He said something loudly which completely escaped me. I was still checking out the damage, there was none. Not a scratch. Relieved, I got out too. It is obviously not a big deal, I thought. The man muttered something about women not being good drivers or something or the other. He started to get inside my car, probably wanted to reverse it. I told him I am very much capable of doing it on my own. He continue shouting, now pointing a finger at me. I realized this was unnecessary, I wanted to get out of it. At the same time, I wanted to stand up. People were gathering around us. They seemed to all know who he was. This seemed to egg him on, he was encouraged to shout louder. He called me a 'kutiya", and the regular ma-behen galis.
This had snowballed. I was digesting it, trying to shout him down. I told him to lower his finger and maintain distance as I started towards my car. He pulled me back and pushed me. Grabbed my clothes. This was getting out of hand. I looked around for help. There was a crowd now. Boys were whispering to each other and laughing. He slapped me. He told me that everyone was mocking me, and that's what happens to girls of 'my kind.' I pleaded with a few old men, asked for help. Everyone told me to move my car, everyone was in a hurry to leave. "hume toh jaane do." I tried to explain that the moment I move my car, the man would also be able to drive off. I did not want that. I had called the cops, so naturally wanted him to be there when the PCR van reached the scene. I stood in front of his car, refusing to let him go. He continued using bad language, showed me the finger. He announced that his father is a DIG, and calling the cops won't help. He moved his car, moving me along with it. It stuck me he won't stop short of running me over. I was in tears. I felt utterly alone. And then I had a breakdown in the middle of the road.
It's the worst feeling in a public space. It's when you're utterly helpless that even an open space and broad daylight don't come to rescue. There were smiling faces, some concerned. Not one helping hand. I felt vulnerable as an individual. It's that feeling of being an outsider, that finally does you in. I reversed my car, shaking. Crying. I was ashamed, I don't know why. Reason didn't exist anymore. There was no sense of right.
My folks reached there soon, shocked at my appearance. Must have been a sight; tear-streaked face, disheveled hair, visibly shaking, angry, passers-by stopping to check out the damsel in distress.
The cops were helpful, commenting on how the crowds that gathered with candles to protest never really came to rescue. It was a matter-of-fact statement. The enormity of it made me sad, but it also made me stop crying. My folks tracked down the guy. He was a resident of Shahpur Jat, a Pawan Pawar. It made sense that he behaved a certain way in a public space. He probably had a reputation to keep. His father is powerful, I wondered what he himself did. Does he have a family, a child? A woman in the house?
The cops asked me to go with them to his place to identify him. In the commotion, I didn't realize that his presence should have been made available to me in a police station and not his own house. Anyway. He had a very old father, retired DIG. They're Jats. My aunt told him so are we. I protested that it didn't matter, that I just needed to see the son and leave. The man wasn't around, and his father refused to get him there in the first place. He used the classic "You're like my daughter" argument. I burst out. Then, I wasn't anyone's daughter, or sister, or a woman. I was an individual with integrity, I wanted my rights. I wanted to get out of this nightmare. The father, he carried a walking stick, kept on apologizing and calling me adamant and a liar. In the same breath. I noticed the double-speak but I was beyond indignation. I told him upon his insistence, that an apology would suffice. My aunt agreed. The son finally came, refused to apologize. Glared at me, and upon more emotional blackmail by his father said, "sorry, okay?"
I couldn't help but laugh. They must have thought I was mad. Maybe I was. And I was getting madder by the minute. I told the cops that I didn't want to be in that space anymore. I wanted to file an FIR. I succumbed to the process. I called my father, used the contacts. The SHO was called, the IO was instructed. I called up people at work, helpful souls (particularly Soni) immediately came forward. Influential voices were raised. In times like these, an inexperienced mind like mine might not understand the due process that is attached at the hip to our legal system. It's when you most need your people, emotionally and otherwise, no? Mind your words with the cops, the IO (a lady named Rita) was indulging in diplomatic speech. It seemed clear that nothing less than a powerful intervention would be accepted. The poor old father of the man followed us to the police station, with the egoistic son in tow. Tapping his walking stick up and down the stairs, he kept on apologizing. I was overwhelmed with emotions. My family from Jaipur kept on calling, friends' mothers were calling.
Hours later I lie in bed, drafting this. This is my space, this is my city. I've lived here for 7 years, a young girl learning my ways. The city had always left me with that tiny ray of hope, of being able to see the goodness in the corners. Never before has it exposed itself so blatantly. I've never felt more powerless as a citizen. I don't want to depend on the politics of the process. I ask, how easy is it for us to see each other as just human beings? Not men/women, or belonging to a particular caste, or a certain area. More importantly, how easy is it for us to break free from the prejudice that walks ahead of us. I do not know this man. The crowds only seemed to aggravate the matter. He was fitting into a stereotypical figure that was crafted for him, by us a society. Maybe I was too. I am trying to resolve the emotions I am feeling, trying to make sense.
All logic escapes me.
So glad you had the courage to see this through to some sort of resolution, if you can even call it that. As much as the whole thing is despicable, I'm sure you'll be stronger for it, as will everyone else who reads this. For what it's worth, there are people, albeit a few, out there who will always jump out to help. God knows we need more though.
ReplyDeleteI'm at a loss of words here. All I can say is I'm sorry.
ReplyDeleteI can't disagree with anything you wrote. The people, the politics, the helplessness as a citizen. I feel ashamed being categorized as a "delhi guy"...when most delhi guys can stand in a crowd watching and mocking a girl being humiliated to such an extent without reason.
I can't help but apologise.
This will probably sound like complete bullshit to you...but there's still goodness in the corners.
It's rare...but it's there.
It leaves me no doubt , that you must have retaliated the very way I've known you to...kudos to your spirit of fighting back with such resolve.
ReplyDeleteMay god give you the strength to overcome this 'disturbance' in your life divya.
Take care...
Tks for standing up to this brute and the 'powerful' father. Everyday security for a woman in public space is shrinking
ReplyDeleteIm an enraged by this incident and I am also horrified that I can actually relate to it. While reading your blog not only was I thinking that its good that you stood up to that man but also that the parking lot in shahpurjat just gives me the creeps every time I go there and that maybe they need to clear it out and remove those useless drivers and extra rif raf. But this then goes back to the point of where all are we going to deploy police and how many corners of this city/NCR are we going to have to "avoid". Its such a shame. The worst part is that almost any self respecting woman in Delhi would have faced a situation where a man does something and when you retaliate the loosers around just look at you and tell you to stop making a scene, embarrass you and mock you about making a scene cos youre a woman. Apologies for the tirade but as a woman I am very glad that you took him to the cops and had the guts to do what alot of us would have shied away from. Thanks you.
ReplyDelete*Thank you
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to let you know that I was really sad and angered after reading your piece on the ordeal you went through.
ReplyDeleteStatus of women in Indian society is beyond low, irrespective of caste/creed/colour/religion/social status/income etc.
I don't know what I would've done if something like that happened around me. I'd like to think that I'll help. Alas, the cops hit the nail, that we can have silent protests and candle marches, but do those very same people take action, sigh, only passively.
I would also like to believe that I am also a Jat but to protect people than to walkover on lesser humans like this shameless MAN did; if he calls himself; I must admit, I must remember that first I am a Human Being who must know to respect one & all round the clock....I do not know what Pleasure this guy must have got after committing such heinous act & he should be taught a lesson once & for all ...I hope this message reaches to many more such Pawan Pawars Still residing & ready to do it again & again without any shame in Delhi Roads...I would certainly like to die killing such people than to see this re occur in our own city Delhi which is our National Pride
ReplyDeleteHi Divya ,
ReplyDeleteIf you ever need anything or any sort of help at any point of time. Please feel free to contact me.
I'll be more than happy to be able to be of some help.Also not trying to creep you out or seem any bit weird, me showing my concern in a comment will hardly be of any use to you if in future you have to go through idiots like him.. But I am sure my number will.. I am usually around tilak marg cause that's where my college is .. College of Art..
I am putting my number here, 8860183167 .. You are an extremely brave girl and so happy you took him to the station.. The legal system is already on your side .. He was terribly wrong .. Take care Divya ..
Divya I feel like I owe you an apology as a Delhiite that we have let things come to this in our lovely city... I still choose to call it a lovely city as there are many little corners where I see a ray of hope that can augur a new era for not just Delhi but the entire nation... I promise you that in the coming year I personally will get together with a bunch of friends and figure out ways to make a contribution in improving the situation... Till then, please don't lose hope and keep fighting...
ReplyDeleteSuch a terminally sick society we live in, and these are some of the symptoms.
ReplyDeleteSheesh! Dashcams. So that one could at least post a video of these plebs at it.
ReplyDeleteYou have shown courage to share your story openly. Even more so in naming the accused. I hope many more people at least start talking about what they are going through everyday so that we learn to accept the fact that this mindset is an unfortunate norm of our society and it must change.
ReplyDeletePlease know that you should be immensely proud of yourself for standing up for yourself in your capacity. I, being a woman who has lived in Delhi for almost 28 years, can understand what you went through. We've all been there at some point and most of us simply walk away from it. But you didn't. I admire you for that. Its difficult to think straight when you're in the middle of such a situation and you showed immense strength. And this gives others the strength to stand up for themselves. Thanks for sharing. This must be extremely overwhelming. I hope you get past it soon. Never stop doing the right thing. You did great.
ReplyDelete- Someone who loves and hates this city at the same time
I am so emotional and angry reading this! I really hope you get some sort of closure... I use to be in that area a LOT.... If I find out that one of my friends left you... There will be trouble... You are not alone <3
ReplyDeleteIf only there were more like you...I feel sorry for all that you had to go through and enraged at the spineless behaviour of the people gathered there. I think its the collective anger of so many individuals like you which has brought forces like the AAP to the forefront. I hope the Police has taken some action, if not please post again and keep us updated. I offer to help you here in whatever capacity I can. I see hope in the current govt. I am sure we'll make that pig repent. I am proud of you Divya, even while you were in distress you didn't let him walk all over you.
ReplyDeleteTake care.
Heartbreaking. :(
ReplyDeleteA few months ago, I - in my car - was once waiting at a traffic light, when I saw - through my rear view mirror - a car approach without slowing down. Seconds later, it rammed into my car from the back.
I immediately got out of the car to see what the damage was like (there was hardly any). But what I instead saw was genuine terror in the eyes of the woman driver. She quickly locked herself from the inside, and rolled up her windows, possibly expecting me to physically assault her.
This took me by surprise, because the reaction of male drivers in such situations would be to get out, argue, or if nothing else, say sorry.
But there she was, terrified, scared for her life. It seemed like her response to the situation was coming from not just this accident, but from a string of experiences and conditioning that comes with living in Delhi.
So I told her softly to concentrate on the road while driving (I had noticed she wasn't looking ahead, seconds before her car hit mine), and I drove off. But the whole incident was yet another reminder to me how women in Delhi experience the city: as a cold, harsh, hostile environment.
What dismays me further is the realization of how hard it would be to change things. It isn't merely a law and order problem. The way the crowded treated you - the way that man treated you - shows that it is a cultural problem with no easy fix.
But this shouldn't stop us from trying. It can get better. Full respect to you for taking it up officially and going after that guy! Assholes like him (and others in the crowd) make Delhi a difficult place for all of us to live, more so women.
I think you have been amazing. I went thro something very similar in 04', at that time I felt very isolated and scared. Eventually, I got bullied into withdrawing the complaint. Please, take support from wherever you can. Stay angry, if it helps. Don't let anyone push you into doing anything. I feel deeply ashamed of letting fear dictate me back then (but I am not saying you have to follow through if you don't want to). Take care. Don't want to put my number here but my email id is annapurna.verma@gmail.com. Take good care.
ReplyDeleteIt was extremely painful to read this.
ReplyDeleteI remember, as children, we all were told that man is a social animal however, looks like some have forgotten the "Social" part and are just animals. I sometimes wonder, whom should we blame? Is it the Govt or the legal system or is it the family where that animal was born? I live in Mumbai and yes, crimes occurs everywhere but why Delhi and its NCR is becoming so unsafe? The Govt. and the legal system will act only after the crime has taken place but as a family, we need to educate our sons, brothers, fathers and other family men to respect a woman so that such incident does not happen again.
Be safe and God bless You
https://twitter.com/abhinav023
I salute your courage and I'm sorry for what you went through. This makes me ashamed of being a man, what a disgrace! Love and support from Lahore
ReplyDeleteRegardless of gender few Human Beings have acted to such strong spirit and taking the guilty to law and standing your ground, I personally admire you and seek motivation from your tale.
ReplyDeleteWe need more persons like you who can take a call and stick to do what is correct.
And I wonder what makes such males behave in such way (if that even be considered a way), had they ever been never in company of females, hadn't been mother around feeding him, taking care, sister adoring, fighting lovingly, and friends making one such male understand what true behaviour a female deserves.
I am never against those candle light marches and other actions, but change and action start from one own self, and that is what I truly believe in.
And that sorry excuse of a male and that sorry excuse of society around him will never ever get out of their shithole lives.
This is horrible- i get so angry reading this. I m a single woman living in Delhi and this is what i fear the most..Stupid men who think they can get away with anything..i m happy to see women take a stand and not take BS from such men..and i m ashamed to learn that no one came to rescue..horrible.
ReplyDeleteDivya you have been extremely courageous.... I wish there were more people like you who can take a stand... You have fought back and been counted where it matters... I just wish the so called men standing around were also man enough to take on that guy there and then... I agree with Sidharth that its not a law and order problem but a cultural one which we have inherited.... I just wish that we would not pass this hypocracy and this misplaced belief of man being supreme to our kids and at least they will have a better tommorow.
ReplyDeleteHi all, thank you for reading this. Your support makes it easier for me to resolve.:)
ReplyDeleteAccidentally stumbled onto this.. And i am glad i have.
ReplyDeleteThis indecency with females really has gone through the roof. Issue is, that with money and so called 'emancipation' of the lower middle class, they have got wealth and the right to stand in any public space due to equal rights, but money can never buy class.
Our govt has been such useless one, even when the ruling party's supremo is a lady herself, they have failed to check the rampant misbehavior towards the females.
What i could confirm from your write up, is what i have long believed..that people with poor upbringing are finding it increasingly difficult to adjust to ways of decent citizens. They think shouting/fighting will give them their level of comfort and they ll be able to establish themselves atleast in the situations. Hence they dont think twice before uttering expletives and eventually they get physical. Depending upon the gender, they crank up the profanities and scuffle.
It is heart warming to see that you had the courage to bear it all and see to it that the arrogant knucklehead was put in his place. Though not a surety that he ll learn, but he def has got a dose. More than anything, you have grown as a person and i hope you ll gain strength from all this.
World is not devoid of sane people. Just that they are not around most of the times.
Our govt has failed, but people like you will ensure India still has more than embers of life in it. Keep it up Divya, may your courage and gumption inspire people far and wide.